Although American Writer Edgar Allan Poe is mainly popular for his tales of mystery and the macabre, he also contributed to the genre of crime fiction in a most impressive way. In particular his 1841 short story The Murders in the Rue...
moreAlthough American Writer Edgar Allan Poe is mainly popular for his tales of mystery and the macabre, he also contributed to the genre of crime fiction in a most impressive way. In particular his 1841 short story The Murders in the Rue Morgue is widely regarded as the very “first modern detective story” (cf. Silverman 171, or Meyers 123). According to
Grimstad, “a remarkable number of the genre’s defining features were already in place” (83). Poe’s story clearly meets the requirements of the traditional detective story, which e.g. the Encyclopaedia Britannica defines as a “type of popular literature in which a crime is
introduced and investigated and the culprit is revealed” (“Detective Story”). However, Edgar Allan Poe’s short story The Black Cat, published for the first time in the Saturday Evening Post in 1843, does not belong to the genre of detective fiction. It simply lacks a detective who is investigating a case. Moreover, the identity of “the culprit is [not]
revealed” at the end (ibid), but is in fact perfectly known to the reader from the very beginning. Since there are both murder(s), murderer, and victim(s), The Black Cat, nonetheless, falls into the general category of crime fiction. The many literary critics who have examined and analyzed the text, have focused on completely different aspects though, arriving at results which are often quite incompatible with each other. Stephen Rachman credits The Black Cat as having something to do with Poe’s supposed alcoholism (“Poe’s Drinking, Poe’s Delirium: The Privacy of Imps”), whereas Sean J. Kelly examines the way masturbation, or onanism, was dealt with1 (“I blush, I burn, I shudder, while I pen the damnable atrocity”). John H. McElroy sees The Black Cat as an example of Poe’s sense of humour (“The Kindred Artist; or, the Case of The Black Cat”), Susan Amper questions Poe’s reliability and seriousness as an author (“Untold Story: The Lying Narrator in The Black Cat”). Last to mention here, Kousik Adhikari investigates the role played by psychology in Poe’s short stories (“Psychology in Crime and Confession: A Critical Study into Poe’s Short Stories The Tell-Tale Heart and The Black Cat”). These are only a few examples, many other aspects dealt with by other authors could easily be added. Though the findings of all the papers mentioned are undoubtedly valuable in many ways, few authors interpreted The Black Cat as a crime story. By analyzing and reading The
Black Cat as crime fiction then, this paper attempts to take a fresh and independent look at the text. More specifically, through literary analysis, its author will pay particular attention to the way Poe makes the narrator of The Black Cat render his confession, as well as present and
examine his crime(s) and motive(s). Other aspects of Poe’s tale are not analyzed, since that would clearly exceed the scope of this paper. Its principal purpose remains to look at the nature of the narrator’s crimes and his motive(s) for committing them.