TVTropes Now available in the app store!
Open

Follow TV Tropes

Casting Gag

Go To

Casting Gag (trope)
Top: Laurence Olivier, mostly known for his adaptations of Shakespearean plays note 
Bottom: Kenneth Branagh, known mostly for his adaptations of Shakespearean plays, as Laurence Olivier note 

This is where an entire role mirrors or parodies an entire previous role or Real Life situation of the actor. A conscious casting choice can be assumed; thus, it can also apply to cameos and guest stars. This forms a small joke or minor piece of merriment. Note that the gag is entirely dependent on the casting and the role rather than some later effected plot or dialogue. Compare Real Role, Fictional Actor, which may involve some element of a casting gag but is not usually one itself.

Contrastingly, an Actor Allusion is when the role being played can be nothing like the actor's real life or previous roles, but contains a Famous Role Shout Out: an allusion to the actor's work, but nothing more.

An actor can use this self-consciously when parodying themselves for Adam Westing. Compare with Playing Against Type, when an actor's role is (often consciously) very different from their typical ones, though this is less likely to be a gag. If the gag is that the character being played is untalented in something the actor excels in, then it's Irony as She Is Cast. If the Casting Gag is that the actor appeared in an earlier version of the same story, it's a Remake Cameo. If not only the actor appeared in an earlier version of the same story, but is cast as a parental figure for the character they played in that earlier version, it's a Predecessor Casting Gag. Compare also to Actor-Shared Background, when the gag doesn't reference a large part of the actor's real life but matches certain elements. See also I Want You to Meet an Old Friend of Mine. Stunt Casting is often done with the aim of shoehorning in this trope.


Examples subpages:

Other examples:

    open/close all folders 

    Audio Plays 
  • Big Finish Doctor Who: As the original Wilkin had been played by Gerald Campion, best known for playing the titular role in Billy Bunter of Greyfriars School, Wilkin from the 2003 remake was played by Melvyn Hayes, as director Nicholas Pegg knew Hayes had appeared alongside Campion in that same series.
  • In Sumsi, a German-language audio play series based on the titular bee mascot of bank Raiffeisen, the titular bee is voiced by Scarlet Lubowski, best known for voicing the titular character in the German dub of the anime Maya the Bee.

    Films — Animation 

    Literature 

    Music 
  • For his album Rock Swings Paul Anka covered Bon Jovi's "It's My Life" which references the song "My Way" by Frank Sinatra, which Anka wrote.
  • Peter Gabriel's "The Barry Williams Show" is from the point of view of a trashy Reality Television show host, but the title wasn't meant to reference any specific celebrity, and the name "Barry Williams" was just meant to be as ordinary-sounding as possible. Peter Gabriel subsequently learned that there was in fact a TV star of that name, the American actor is best known for playing Greg from The Brady Bunch, so he got him to make a cameo in the music video... Ironically enough, he plays an audience member, not the host.
  • P!nk's "Revenge", a Revenge Ballad about her and her friends getting back on an ex who treated her badly, has a guest verse from Eminem, infamous for channelling his real-life Destructive Romance with Kim Scott into songs about getting (bloody) revenge on her. Pink doesn't give any details about what her revenge is, and all Slim describes is intentionally cheating on his girl to make her feel bad... but his presence is enough to imply some violence to the plans. This is reinforced by the video, which is pretty gory for Top 40 pop.
  • The voice provider of Vocaloid's Megpoid/Gumi is Megumi Nakajima, who had previously voiced the Idol Singer, Ranka Lee, from Macross Frontier. Her design is also very similar to Ranka's and has the same color scheme as her.
  • For her video for duet with Chris Stapleton "We Don't Even Fight Anymore", Carly Pearce cast Lucy Hale, who Pearce used to sing backup for, as the female lead.

    Radio 

    Theatre 
  • In 2009, Cate Blanchett played the title character in an Australian production of Richard II. Richard and Queen Elizabeth I (who Blanchett previously played in Elizabeth) have famously been compared—Elizabeth herself allegedly even said: "I am Richard II; know ye not that?" in response to hearing about a production of that very play, which was banned for depicting the overthrow of a king of England (she'd already suspected the people who requested the play from Shakespeare's troupe of plotting against her).
  • Anne Hathaway's role as the lead in the 2009 Shakespeare in the Park production of Twelfth Night, though it's more of a casting pun. Her name is the same as Shakespeare's wife.
  • Jesse L. Martin, the original Collins in RENT, was in the Rock Opera Bright Lights Big City as the protagonist's best friend, who expressed disdain for "yuppies" and enjoyed using certain, um, recreational substances.
  • Darren Criss, known for playing Harry in A Very Potter Musical, took over Daniel Radcliffe's role in How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying.
  • Arsenic and Old Lace inverted this in the original stage version. The psychotic older brother berates his surgical henchman because someone said he looked like Boris Karloff. In the original Broadway cast, he was played by Boris Karloff. As the production was still making money at the time the film was set to be produced, the stage producers wouldn't allow Karloff out of his contract long enough to appear in the film version, and so the film producers had to make do with a heavily-made-up Raymond Massey. Karloff did get to reprise the role for a TV movie adaptation in 1962.
  • For the 1951 West End production of A Streetcar Named Desire, Tennessee Williams personally cast Vivien Leigh—who was still best known for playing Scarlett O'Hara at the time—as the mentally damaged Southern Belle Blanch Dubois, whose inability to cope with the loss of her family's ancestral plantation tragically costs her her sanity. The casting choice carried over to the well-known film adaptation released the same year (see "Film" above).
  • The 2011 production of Company cast Neil Patrick Harris, an openly gay engaged man, as a bachelor who strings women along and disdains marriage.
  • The original Broadway production of Shrek: The Musical cast John Tartaglia, a famous Broadway puppeteer and Muppet performer, as Pinocchio, a puppet.
  • John Cleese voices God in Spamalot, a Broadway musical based on Monty Python and the Holy Grail. His lines are provided by a vocal recording in nearly every production, allowing him to play the role without needing to be physically present.
  • The original Broadway production of Young Frankenstein features Shuler Hensley as the Monster, having previously played the part in the film Van Helsing.

    Video Games 

    Web Animation 

    Web Videos 


 
Feedback

Video Example(s):

Top

Captain America Reveal

Deadpool and Wolverine meet MCU Captain America (played by Chris Evans) in the Void. Or do they?

How well does it match the trope?

4.7 (30 votes)

Example of:

Main / FakeOutTwist

Media sources:

Report