Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Legal Theory

description13,556 papers
group115,315 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
Legal Theory is the study of the nature, purposes, and principles of law. It examines the philosophical foundations of legal systems, the relationship between law and morality, and the interpretation of legal texts, aiming to understand the underlying concepts that govern legal practices and institutions.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Legal Theory is the study of the nature, purposes, and principles of law. It examines the philosophical foundations of legal systems, the relationship between law and morality, and the interpretation of legal texts, aiming to understand the underlying concepts that govern legal practices and institutions.

Key research themes

1. How does syntactic structure influence legal authority and the execution of law in the age of AI and automation?

This theme investigates the role of grammar, syntactic delegation, and computational linguistics in shaping legal authority and the formal execution of legal norms. It highlights how language models (LLMs), AI-powered systems, and automated processes reinterpret legal texts not through semantic understanding but via syntactical compliance, fundamentally transforming legal authorship, responsibility, and the operationalization of law into executable forms.

Key finding: This paper introduces the concept of regla compilada, defining legal speech that can be executed by non-human systems based on structural syntactic criteria rather than semantic interpretation. It identifies four formal... Read more
Key finding: This study demonstrates that large language model-generated institutional texts systematically eliminate syntactic subjects through passive constructions, nominalizations, and elided agents, transferring discursive agency to... Read more
Key finding: By analyzing a corpus of AI-generated crypto whitepapers, the paper empirically shows that investor trust increasingly depends on syntactic coherence (depth, nominalizations, modality) rather than verifiable content. It... Read more
Key finding: This research identifies that AI classifiers in corporate ERPs rely disproportionately on syntactic patterns such as nominalizations and coordination depth rather than semantic finance content, causing misclassifications.... Read more
Key finding: This article reveals that AI-generated clinical diagnostic texts systematically remove conventional linguistic hedges signaling uncertainty, effectively delegating clinical authority syntactically and producing legal... Read more
Key finding: Arguing from legal philosophy, this paper critically addresses whether AI can be a 'legal author' given absence of intention, asserting that law creation does not necessarily require authorial intent. It draws on theory to... Read more

2. What are the jurisprudential implications of judicial regret and the evolving role of interpretation and authority in legal systems?

This research theme explores the normative and interpretive challenges that arise when judges express regret over past decisions, questioning the stability of precedent and the ontology of law. It examines the fluidity of legal authority, shifting between positivist assumptions, pragmatic contextualism, and the assumptions surrounding interpretation, intention, and authority, highlighting how regret informs reform and the evolution of constitutional interpretation.

Key finding: The paper systematically documents instances of U.S. Supreme Court Justices expressing regret over key rulings, revealing judicial regret as a widespread, consequential phenomenon. It argues for integrating judicial regret... Read more
Key finding: Using José Medina's Pragmatic Contextualism, the paper reconceptualizes legal interpretation as emerging from discursive agency within evolving contexts rather than fixed cognitive or decisional models. This approach... Read more
Key finding: Beyond the question of AI as executable author, this paper also interrogates the philosophical foundations of legal authorship and intentionality, positing that law can be law without human intention behind its creation. This... Read more

3. How do social and constitutional principles mediate inequalities and normative demands in law, particularly regarding citizenship, public health, and socio-legal frameworks?

This theme critically analyzes the interplay between law, social norms, constitutional principles, and lived realities, focusing on systemic inequalities, normative authority, and the framing of rights. It explores how legal categories such as citizenship and public health acquire multifaceted constitutional significance, revealing dissonance between formal rules and material conditions that produce justice or perpetuate exclusion.

Key finding: Proposes a nuanced taxonomy of citizenship status, expanding beyond binary formal definitions to reveal layered constitutional positions with vastly different material realities. The taxonomy exposes systemic barriers and... Read more
Key finding: Argues public health should be recognized as a foundational normative principle constituting the modern constitutional state, distinct from but including the right to health. It systematically conceptualizes public health's... Read more
Key finding: This paper elucidates how deeply ingrained social norms undermine legal efficacy in gender equality law across the EU by creating conflicting normative expectations that impair compliance and enforcement. It develops a... Read more
Key finding: Critiques conventional jurisprudence’s focus on recognition, proposing an alternative Relational Legal Pluralism that frames law as emerging from lived relational harm and spatial abandonment. It offers a jurisprudence... Read more
Key finding: Analyzing Harold J. Laski’s Marxist-informed theory, the paper elucidates the dynamic interrelation between law, revolution, and democracy as dialectically intertwined processes. It highlights Laski’s view of law as both a... Read more

4. How does historical and comparative legal theory illuminate the emergence and evolution of legal rules and institutions?

This theme focuses on the philosophical and historical foundations of law, including natural law and positivism, the codification of custom into written law, and the influence of socio-economic factors on legal form. It investigates how the practice of lawmaking evolved from unwritten customs to codified rules, influencing claims of legal objectivity and the role of law within society.

Key finding: Provides a comprehensive overview tracing the shift from natural law theories, rooted in universal principles discovered by reason, to legal positivism emphasizing enacted law’s authority. It highlights the historical impetus... Read more
Key finding: Offers a critical examination of property law’s modern paradigm, revealing its underpinning legal positivist ideology. It contrasts the idealized, exclusionary concept of ownership with the probabilistic and context-dependent... Read more
Key finding: By illustrating judicial regret alongside foundational legal theories, this paper indirectly sheds light on the contingency of law and the diachronic evolution of its institutional interpretation.

All papers in Legal Theory

In the wake of the 1994 genocide, Rwanda’s government created the Gacaca courts to hold suspected perpetrators accountable. Although much has been written about these courts, researchers know comparatively less about the 250,000... more
This study provides a detailed description of the process by which parents choose schools for their children and the process by which urban schools adjust to the necessity of convincing parents to choose them. The Parent Information... more
This article examines whether a retributivist conception of punishment implies legal moralism and asks what liberalism implies about retributivism and moralism. It makes a case for accepting the weak retributivist thesis that culpable... more
Le droit romain a réglementé les arbres dès l'époque décémvirale. Ils étaient considérés comme des repères naturels durables, permettant d'indiquer les limites des propriétés foncières. Malgré quelques modifications, la plupart des normes... more
IDI -In-depth Interview IEC -Information Education Communication LMIC(s) -Low-and Middle-Income Countrie(s) NCD(s) -Non Communicable Disease(s) PNCD-Patient of Noncommunicable Disease FPNCD -Family of Patient of Noncommunicable Disease... more
Przestępstwo zgwałcenia jest jednym z najbardziej elektryzujących debatę publiczną zagadnień prawa karnego. Aby uniknąć negatywnego napięcia między praktyką i dogmatyką prawniczą a intuicjami moralnymi społeczeństwa, wykładnia jego... more
For vulnerable groups in society, water insecurity and deficient water availability for food production commonly reflect unequal distribution of water volumes, quality, and services within unequal power structures. Water security is... more
Un entretien, en collaboration avec Jean-Louis Halpérin, pour Les Cahiers Portalis (2024/2, N°14).
Марченя П.П. Человек и право в кризисном ритме российской истории: русское правосознание как фактор цивилизационной идентичности [Всероссийская научно-практическая конференция Право как форма бытия человека (к 300-летию И. Канта)] //... more
L'endettement public massif, surtout lorsqu'il atteint des niveaux records comme en France en 2025 (plus de 115 % du PIB), ne crée pas que des perdants. Il génère aussi des gagnants cachés, souvent liés à des mécanismes financiers... more
Cilj rada je istražiti sporove u svezi s povredom žiga Europske unije (EU) budući da Bosni i Hercegovini (BiH) predstoji put usklađivanja propisa s pravnom stečevinom EU. Učinkovit, dobro osmišljen i uravnotežen sustav intelektualnog... more
propiedad intelectual no presenta ninguna utilidad social ni económica. Eso sostiene algún grupo actualmente en relación con dicha institución. El presente documento aborda la justificación deontológica de la propiedad intelectual para... more
La Décision n°42/CNO/RIC/2022 du Conseil National de l’Ordre des Avocats en RDC impose une attestation préalable pour plaider hors ressort. Si cette mesure poursuit des objectifs légitimes de discipline et de traçabilité, sa mise en œuvre... more
Fecha de recepción: 11/06/2024 Fecha de aceptación: 15/07/2024 SUMARIO: 1. Introduction. 2. AI wrongs. 3. What are punitive damages? Its nature. 4. When? Cases to be awarded. 5. How? Its assessment. 6. To whom? The beneficiary. 7.... more
This article critically examines Rwanda’s transitional justice mechanisms in the aftermath of the 1994 genocide against the Tutsi, situating them within the broader debates on accountability for international crimes and reconciliation in... more
This article examines whether the separation of powers is effective in the United Kingdom and Sri Lanka by comparison of key statutes, and case laws, from the Constitutional Reform Act 2005 and the creation of Supreme Court strengthened... more
Published in K.-D. Schunck, M. Augustin, eds., “Lasset uns Brücken bauen…”, BEATAJ 42 (Frankfurt a. M., Peter Lang, 1998), 67-71.
The chapter ‘Pragmatic Encroachment, the Problem of Sufficiency, and Legal Reasons’ explores the intricate relationship between practical and epistemic justification. It begins by reconstructing a distinctive formulation of the Unity... more
This open access book introduces the first systematic approach to the debate on the unity or fragmentation of practical reasoning and its profound implications for legal philosophy. Bringing together some of the foremost legal... more
Christentum und Privatrecht im Vormärz, in: Nils Jansen, Peter Oestmann (Hgg.), Rechtsgeschichte heute. Religion und Politik in der Geschichte des Rechts. Schlaglichter einer Ringvorlesung, Tübingen 2014, S. 181–199.
Thibaut und die historische Rechtsschule, in: Christian Hattenhauer, Klaus-Peter Schroeder u. Christian Baldus (Hgg.), Anton Friedrich Justus Thibaut (1772–1840). Bürger und Gelehrter, Tübingen 2017, S. 59–76.
A feature on photography historian and tutor Kevin Casha by David Rossi
This article by a judcial civil rights organization located in Brazil argues that lawyers, like Scott Erik Stafne, must have the political right to challenge judicial rulings.
a survey on the legitimation of a natural of reason; to be publ. in: Zeitschrift für Altorientalische und Biblische Rechtsgeschichte (ZAR) 31, 2025
Nominative laws—laws named after particular victims of violence or injustice such as Martyn's Law, Sarah's Law and Awaab's Law—have become increasingly prominent in the UK. In this article, we offer the first sustained attempt to explore... more
FinMaP-Working Paper No.46 -P a g e | 2 This paper applies Markov-switching multifractal (MSM) processes to model and forecast carbon dioxide (CO2) emission price volatility, and compares their forecasting performance to the standard... more
Bản ý kiến góp ý về thủ tục tố tụng tài Tòa án chuyên biệt thuộc Trung tâm tài chính quốc tế IFC gửi cho Tổ biên tập Tòa án nhân dân tối cao ngày 10/10/2025.
In the current global political arena, liberal democracies face significant strain due to the rise of populist movements, challenges to constitutional integrity, and the gradual erosion of the rule of law. Populism, frequently marked by... more
This research analyzes the jurisprudential dialog that the Mexican Supreme Court of Justice has held with the CIDH around the economic, social and cultural rights (ESCR), as well as some interpretations of the CADH and other international... more
In this text, I aim to link Sellars’s view on intention with a fundamental Hartian insight: that a normative domain cannot be fully understood without considering the perspective of its participants. Following this insight, I delve... more
The essay outlines the key events of the Crusade against Aragon in 1285, focusing particularly on naval confrontations, especially the significant battle that occurred near the Formigues Islands. In addition to acknowledging Roger de... more
Knjiga/monografija o prirodi i djelovanju Visokog Predstavnika (High Representative) u BiH. Ključna teza glasi da je riječ o sui generis tiranijskoj funkciji s izrazito lošim i štetnim posljedicama po BiH u svakom smislu. Poglavlje 5... more
an overview on the literary history and theology of the Decalogues in Exod 20 and Deut 5; publ. in: Religion in Geschichte und Gegenwart, vol. II, Tübingen 1999, 625-628.
Cruelty in matrimonial milieu is criminally prohibited offence. The offence being cognizable and non-bailable vests enormous powers in the hands of police and complainant as well. Police can cause havoc under the guise of policing such... more
an overview on the interpretation of the Talion; publ. in Religion in Geschichte und Gegenwart (RGG). 4th ed., vol. VIII, Tübingen 2005, 19-20
This study is organized around two questions: When is the state authority legitimate? And who has the morally legitimate authority to punish so-called criminals? Through a critical analysis of some philosophical accounts of state... more
This Essay elaborates in three ways the call for a renewal of social science approaches to international law advanced by Daniel Abebe, Adam Chilton, and Tom Ginsburg. First, while we affirm the importance of what they call the "scientific... more
O trabalho procura identificar e caracterizar as funções sociais da cidade, previstas no art. 182 da Constituição Federal. O desenvolvimento e o conceito de cidade são estudados, bem como a organização política do município brasileiro e a... more
Taking a seminar in 2024 as a starting point, this report contains some reflections about discussions relating to civil law in post Soviet states. #CivillawAlmaty #Международнойнаучнопрактическконференции #цивилистическихчтений... more
A személyes és a rendbe öntött igazságosság szintézise [könyvszemle Helmut Coing: A jogfilozófia alapjai című könyvéről (Budapest, Osiris, 1996)].

1996. 4. sz. 420–427. o.

ISSN 0865-4247; elektronikus változat: ISSN 1588-0222
Linguagem é a primeira grande área da capacidade cognitiva humana para a qual estamos começando a obter uma descrição que não é exageradamente simplificada. Graças ao trabalho de linguistas transformacionais contemporâneos, 1 uma... more
An emphasis on democracy is typical of action research. Therefore, theories of modern democracy can be applied within the field of school development through action research. According to Jürgen Habermas, the promotion of democratic... more
Download research papers for free!