Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

iLuddite

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Oct 9, 2023
619
1,176
Seattle, WA
Anyone know yet whether the M5 iPad Pro is going to feature a Display Pulse Smoothing (PWM) accessibility option a là iPhones 17/Air?

I for one am most curious….
 
I’m going to say no since the display is literally the same. The iPhones got a higher outdoor brightness compared to the previous generation so maybe something is different about them.

Guess we’ll see.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: iLuddite
I’m going to say no since the display is literally the same. The iPhones got a higher outdoor brightness compared to the previous generation so maybe something is different about them.

Guess we’ll see.
Or, hopefully, the appearance of Display Pulse Smoothing is not primarily because of new display characteristics, but because Apple finally acknowledges the issue and decided to add a customisation.
 
It appears that there is no such option according to Reddit.

However, interestingly, the new iPad Pro appears to use DC dimming at brightnesses above 50% according to the German Notebookcheck review. They mention it in the Display section, translated as "We still measure PWM flickering at 240 Hz, but DC dimming with a lower amplitude is now used above a brightness of 50%". The PWM graphs also appear to show DC dimming at 100% and 75% brightness. Wonder if this may alleviate some issues so long as the brightness is above 50%.
 
I am a bit confused after reading that review in german. Is that really DC dimming as they wrote above 50%? DC dimming should look like a straight line, with no dips, but the graph still shows the dips at 75% brightness.
Another question, the graph at 0% brightness is a straight line. Does that mean that if I slide the brightness at the minimum, I will not have PWM?
 
I am a bit confused after reading that review in german. Is that really DC dimming as they wrote above 50%? DC dimming should look like a straight line, with no dips, but the graph still shows the dips at 75% brightness.
Another question, the graph at 0% brightness is a straight line. Does that mean that if I slide the brightness at the minimum, I will not have PWM?

This is the english version. Should help

[https://www.notebookcheck.net/Apple...remely-fast-M5-SoC-and-Wi-Fi-7.1143628.0.html]
 
I am still confused about it and have the same questions. They state DC dimming is used above 50% but I don’t see it on the graph for 75% brightness (or I interpret the graph wrongly). Also the question remains about 0% brightness where on the graph the line is almost straight and no flickering appears. Would sliding the brightness to the lowest level remove the flickering entirely, or is that setting not considered 0% brightness?
 
I am still confused about it and have the same questions. They state DC dimming is used above 50% but I don’t see it on the graph for 75% brightness (or I interpret the graph wrongly). Also the question remains about 0% brightness where on the graph the line is almost straight and no flickering appears. Would sliding the brightness to the lowest level remove the flickering entirely, or is that setting not considered 0% brightness?
if I understand correctly, DC dimming is not going to have a completely flat waveform and will often have a short dip corresponding to each refresh of the display:

However, there seems to be more dips than 120Hz, so it might be some hybrid between DC and PWM dimming. The depth of the dips is quite small though so probably is easier on the eyes. See the waveform for M4 iPad Pro as comparison below - it’s quite a lot worse.

I may be wrong on the above so feel free to correct me
 
  • Like
Reactions: hovscorpion12
To be fair, i know what Apple is doing.

They want users to connect to a monitor to alleviate the problem. That's why they pushed the M5 to 4k/120

That's how they can get away with it on Macbooks. All Macbooks including M1-M5 have PWM, but very small # of people complain since they just connect to monitor by default.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: iLuddite
I was just at the Apple Store trading in toward/picking up an M5 MacBook Pro and completely forgot to look at the new iPads…sorry, folks :confused:

However I did see many peeps picking up the new M5 iPad Pro; the clerk assisting me even said they were definitely more popular than the equivalent MacBook at this juncture as many are likely holding out for the M5 Pro/Max/16” MacBooks.
 
  • Love
Reactions: hovscorpion12
if I understand correctly, DC dimming is not going to have a completely flat waveform and will often have a short dip corresponding to each refresh of the display:

However, there seems to be more dips than 120Hz, so it might be some hybrid between DC and PWM dimming. The depth of the dips is quite small though so probably is easier on the eyes. See the waveform for M4 iPad Pro as comparison below - it’s quite a lot worse.

I may be wrong on the above so feel free to correct me

Thanks for the explanation, it makes sense. I look forward to reading more insights and user’s experiences compared to M4.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.