Table 3 DACCR;| is the absolute value of discretionary accruals of firm i in year t under Modified Jones model (Dechow et al. 1995). In_Sm is the ratio of the standard deviation of earnings to cash flow from operations of firm. Ke is the cost of equity of firm i in year ¢t measured by Easton (2004) model. GROUP is 1 for a firm that belongs to a business group, 0 for a firm that is in a non-business group in year t. Top_4 is 1 for Top 4 client firms, 0 for non-Top 4 client firms in year t. Ln_Fees is the natural logarithm of audit fees of firm i in year ¢. Ln_Assets is natural logarithm of total assets of firm i in year ¢. F_Lev is the ratio of total debt to total assets of firm i in year ¢. ROA is the net income before extraordinary items for a firm i in year ft scaled by total assets. L_Loss takes the value of 1 if firm i in year ¢ and t-/reports negative income before extraordinary items and 0 if otherwise. VOLATILITY is a measure of a stock's average annual price movement to a high and low from a mean price for each year. Panel A: Descriptive statistics for DACCR, In_Sm & Ke sample (n=7,308)