Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Outline

ABC and organizational change: an institutional perspective

2002, Management Accounting Research

https://doi.org/10.1006/MARE.2002.0186

Abstract

Using institutional theory to interpret the role of management accounting in organizational change, the paper reports on a longitudinal empirical study of the implementation of an Activity-Based Costing (ABC) system in the Clearing Department of a UK-based multinational bank. Since the ABC project team was operating at the same time as other change agents (productivity consultants and human resource engineering), their interrelationships are explored through the displacement/establishment of routines and institutionalized practices. The extent and nature of organizational change is evaluated by drawing on the dichotomies of formal versus informal change, revolutionary versus evolutionary change, and regressive versus progressive change (Burns and Scapens, 2000). Tensions were identified between the need to establish ABC as an organizational routine thereby ensuring its reproduction with the less routinized but more revolutionary aspirations of ABM. The ABC team succeeded in institutionalizing a less radical version of ABC that revealed new links between costs and products, but did not go as far as to transform the strategic thinking of the bank's senior management.

Key takeaways
sparkles

AI

  1. The study evaluates ABC's role in organizational change within a UK bank using institutional theory.
  2. Tensions arose between institutionalizing ABC as a routine and the revolutionary aspirations of ABM.
  3. Data revealed new links between costs and products, but did not transform senior management's strategic thinking.
  4. ABC implementation struggled to progress beyond Stage 3 of cost system development.
  5. The research emphasizes the interplay between management accounting and other change agents in organizations.

References (53)

  1. Abrahamson, E., 1991. Managerial fads and fashions: the diffusion and rejection of innova- tions, Academy of Management Review, 16, 586-612.
  2. Adams, M., 1996. Activity based costing (ABC) and the life-insurance industry, Service Industries Journal, 16, 511-526.
  3. Armstrong, P., 1985. Changing management control strategies: the role of competition between accountancy and other organizational professionals, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 10, 129-148.
  4. Armstrong, P., 2002. The costs of activity based management, Accounting, Organisations and Society, 27, 99-120.
  5. Armstrong, P. and Jones, C., 1992. The decline of operational expertise in the knowledge base of management accounting, Management Accounting Research, 3, 53-75.
  6. Baldamus, N., 1972. The role of discoveries in social science, in T. Shanin (ed.) The Rules of the Game, London, Tavistock.
  7. Barley, S. R. and Tolbert, P. S., 1997. Institutionalisation and structuration; studying the links between action and institution, Organisation Studies, 18, 93-117.
  8. Berger, P. and Luckmann, T., 1967. The Social Construction of Reality. A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge, Penguin, Harmondsworth.
  9. Bhimani, A. and Piggott, D., 1992. Implementing ABC: a case study of organisational and behavioural consequences, Management Accounting Research, 3, 119-132.
  10. Bjornenak, T. and Mitchell, F., 2000. A study of the development of the activity based cost- ing, Journal Literature 1987-1998, Paper presented at the MARG workshop on Reflections on Management Accounting Change, London School of Economics.
  11. Bjornenak, T. and Olson, O., 1999. Unbundling management accounting innovations, Manage- ment Accounting Research, 10, 325-328.
  12. Brignall, S., 1997. A contingent rationale for cost system design in services, Management Accounting Research, 8, 325-346.
  13. Burns, J., 2000. The dynamics of accounting change: inter-play between new practices, routines, institutions, power and politics, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability, 13, 566-596.
  14. Burns, J. and Scapens, R. W., 2000. Conceptualising management accounting change: an institutional framework, Management Accounting Research, 11, 3-25.
  15. Cobb, I., Helliar, C. and Innes, J., 1995. Management accounting change in a bank, Management Accounting Research, 6, 155-175.
  16. Cooper, R. and Kaplan, R. S., 1988. How cost accounting distorts product costs, Management Accounting (US), 69, April, 20-27.
  17. Cooper, R. and Kaplan, R. S., 1998. The Design of Cost Management Systems : Text and Cases, 2nd Edition, New Jersey, Prentice Hall.
  18. Cressey, P. and Scott, P., 1992. Employment, technology and industrial relations in UK clearing banks: is the honeymoon over? New Technology, Work and Employment, 7, 83-96.
  19. Daniels, A., 1999. The implementation of an ABC system in ABB, Paper presented at the ENROC conference on management accounting change, University of Manchester.
  20. DiMaggio, P. J. and Powell, W. W., 1983. The iron cage re-visited; institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organisational fields, American Sociological Review, 48, 147-160.
  21. Eden, C. and Huxham, C., 1996. Action research for management research, British Journal of Management, 7, 75-86.
  22. Ezzamel, M., Hoskin, K. and Macve, R., 1990. Managing it all by numbers: a review of Johnson and Kaplan's relevance lost, Accounting and Business Research, 20, 153-166.
  23. Giddens, A., 1984. The Constitution of Society, Cambridge, Polity Press.
  24. Horngren, C., Bhimani, A., Foster, G. and Dalar, S., 1999. Management and Cost Accounting, Europe, Prentice Hall.
  25. Innes, J. and Mitchell, F., 1991. Activity Based Cost Management: A Case Study of Development and Implementation, London, CIMA.
  26. Innes, J. and Mitchell, F., 1997. The application of activity-based costing in the United King- dom's largest financial institutions, The Service Industries Journal, 17, 190-203.
  27. Innes, J., Mitchell, F. and Sinclair, D., 2000. Activity based costing in the UK's largest companies: a comparison of 1994 and 1999 survey results, Management Accounting Research, 11, 349-362.
  28. Johnson, H. T., 1988. Activity based information: a blue-print for world-class management accounting, Management Accounting (US), September, 26-35.
  29. Johnson, H. T., 1992. It's time to stop overselling activity-based concepts: start focusing on customer satisfaction instead, Management Accounting (US), September, 26-35.
  30. Jones, T. C. and Dugdale, D., 2002. The ABC Bandwagon and the Juggernaut of modernity, Accounting, Organisations and Society, 27, 121-163.
  31. Kaplan, R. S., 1998. Innovation action research: creating new management theory and practice, Journal of Management Accounting Research, 10, 89-109.
  32. Kaplan, R. S. and Cooper, R., 1998. Cost and Effect, Boston, Masachusetts, Harvard Business School Press.
  33. Legge, K., 1989. Human resource management: a critical analysis, in J. Storey (ed.) New Perspectives on Human Resource Management, London, Routledge, 19-40.
  34. Mabberley, J., 1992. Activity Based Costing in Financial Institutions, London, Pitman.
  35. Macintosh, N. and Scapens, R. W., 1990. Structuration theory in management accounting, Accounting, Organisations and Society, 15, 455-477.
  36. Malmi, T., 1997. Towards explaining activity-based costing failure: accounting and control in a decentralised organisation, Management Accounting Research, 8, 459-480.
  37. Malmi, T., 1999. Activity-based costing diffusion across organisations: an exploratory empirical analysis of finnish firms, Accounting Organisations and Society, 8, 649-672.
  38. Meyer, J. W. and Rowan, B., 1977. Institutionalised organisations: formal structure as myth and ceremony, American Journal of Sociology, 83, 340-363.
  39. Morgan, G., 1988. Accounting as reality construction: towards a new epistemology for accounting practice, Accounting Organisations and Society, 13, 477-485.
  40. Morris, T., 1986. Innovations in Banking: Business Strategies for Employee Relations, Kent, Croom Helm.
  41. Munro, R., 1995. Managing by ambiguity: an archaeology of the social in the absence of management accounting, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 6, 433-482.
  42. Munson, P., 1990. The Social Construction of MIS in a Hospital, Ph.D. Thesis, Nottingham Polytechnic.
  43. Rosander, K., 1999. Performance management: Prodacapo, Paper presented at the ENROC conference on management accounting change, University of Manchester.
  44. Scapens, R. W., 1990. Researching management accounting practice: the role of case study methods, British Accounting Review, 22, 259-281.
  45. Seal, W. B. and Croft, L., 1997. Professional rivalry and changing management con- trol approaches in UK clearing banks, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, 10, 60-84.
  46. Sephton, M. and Ward, T., 1990. ABC in retail financial services, Management Accounting UK, 68, 29-33.
  47. Shields, M., 1995. An empirical analysis of firms' implementation experiences with activity based costing, Journal of Management Accounting Research, 7, Fall.
  48. Spicer, B., 1992. The resurgence of cost and management accounting: a review of some recent developments in practice, theories and case research methods, Management Accounting Research, 3, 1-37.
  49. Tomkins, C., Rosenberg, D. and Colville, I., 1980. The social process of research: some reflections on developing a multi-disciplinary accounting project, Accounting, Organisations and Society, 5, 247-262.
  50. Tool, M., 1993. The theory of instrumental value: extensions, clarifications, in M. Tool (ed.) Institutional Economics, Boston and London, Kluwer Publishers, 119-159.
  51. Williamson, O. E., 1975. Markets and Hierarchies: Analysis and Antitrust Implications, New York, The Free Press.
  52. Williamson, O. E., 1985. The Economic Institutions of Capitalism, New York, The Free Press.
  53. Willmott, H., 1987. Studying managerial work: a critique and a proposal, Journal of Management Studies, 24, 249-270.

FAQs

sparkles

AI

What are the documented impacts of ABC implementation in non-manufacturing sectors?add

The study finds that ABC introduced significant cost consciousness in the bank, enhancing decision-making through detailed process analysis and highlighting that a normal cheque costs 3p to clear, while a rejected cheque rises to 16p.

How did institutional theory shape the understanding of ABC's role in organizational change?add

The research reveals that institutional theory helps explain the interplay between management accounting practices and broader organizational routines, capturing the uncertainty in ABC implementation outcomes, particularly in an evolving financial context.

What were the limitations of prior management accounting systems in the bank?add

The paper illustrates that before ABC, management accounting was underdeveloped, focusing solely on budgetary controls without linking costs to products or services, leading to a lack of cost-conscious culture.

How did the researcher mitigate bias while collecting qualitative data?add

The researcher employed a participant observation method, fostering close relationships with ABC team members, while triangulating informal conversations with formal interviews and documentary evidence to enhance data validity.

What role did the Human Resource Engineering team play alongside ABC implementation?add

The HRE team acted as an intermediary between management consultants and the ABC team, sharing responsibility for data collection and fostering collaboration, albeit initially struggling to clarify their own objectives.