Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Outline

Kathy Acker's sex negativity

2024, Journal of Lesbian Studies

https://doi.org/10.1080/10894160.2023.2294567

Abstract

This essay situates Kathy Acker’s work in the feminist sex wars debate of the 1980s. I suggest that the critique of Acker’s work as a “nihilist version of the personal is political” is not ungrounded but might more usefully be understood as a “sex negativity” that emerges from specific feminist avant-garde lit- erary devices. I discuss Acker’s early texts, “Politics” (1972) and “Stripper Disintegration” (1973) to show how sexuality defines Acker’s esthetic and political project. I consider the (negative) feminist reception of Acker’s work, lay out how Acker was involved in the pornography debate, and I bring Acker’s work into conversation with Andrea Dworkin’s thought. The essay argues that Acker’s pseudo-autobiographical strategies and montage techniques pose a problem for the feminist politiciz- ing of self-knowledge and the genre of autobiography as a privileged site of identity formation and emancipation. In the reordering of materials, by way of replacing, exchanging, and negating, transformation is made possible by the act of rewrit- ing’s capacity to reveal substitutability. Acker’s “nihilist” feminist politics challenge the self-determination and authenticity often assumed in the politicizing of lived experience. I also suggest that “the lesbian” functions as a phantasmatic figure in Acker’s early work to circumvent the subject-object logic of the por- nographic imagination. In short, Acker’s early work illuminates the complex relation between sexuality, self-objectification, and the act of writing itself. With Acker’s pseudo-autobiographical texts we can conceive of a sex negativity that is not anti-sex but challenges what Michel Foucault calls the “monarchy of sex” through non-positive affirmation.

Key takeaways
sparkles

AI

  1. Acker's work embodies a critique of feminist sex wars, challenging notions of authenticity and self-determination.
  2. The concept of 'sex negativity' in Acker's texts critiques the idea that sexual liberation equates to empowerment.
  3. Acker's pseudo-autobiographical style destabilizes traditional narratives of self-knowledge and identity formation.
  4. The early texts 'Politics' and 'Stripper Disintegration' reveal the complexities of sexuality and self-objectification.
  5. Acker's avant-garde techniques serve as a radical rethinking of sexual politics, emphasizing non-positive affirmation.

References (44)

  1. "I don't like any writing that's manipulative. Newspapers are very manipulative, and probably much more powerful -you're being manipulated all the time. Porn shops are not as manipulative as newspapers." In: "The Pornographic Imagination of Kathy Acker" (1984). Ira Silverberg Papers, box 39. NYU Special Collections 14. For Simone de Beauvoir self-objectification is what defines "woman:" in becoming woman she first makes herself into an object (devenir femme equals se faire objet). For Beauvoir, sexual difference is fundamentally about how the mind grasps the body in our own first-person experience.
  2. Together with among others Gayle Rubin, Pat Califia is one of the co-founders of SAMOIS the lesbian S/M group Acker was involved with.
  3. Panel discussion at the Vrouwenfestival in Amsterdam, 1985.
  4. Acker stated in interviews that she needed the money but in her biography Kraus suggests that Acker was not as poor as she made it seem and was perhaps more interested in the experience itself.
  5. McBride compares Acker's work in the sex industry and new understanding of sexism to Simone Weil's work at the factories: Acker's biographer views Acker's entrance into the sex industry as a compares Acker's new understanding of sexism to Simone Weil's work at the factories: "now, suddenly she was not just part of the working class, but a sex worker, surrounded by other sex workers. It was akin, perhaps, to Simone Weil going to the factories. She acquired a new, deeper under- standing of capitalism and feminism. Stripped of her own class privilege, so to speak, she was now confronting, every week, the violence of male privilege and the male gaze."
  6. Various scholars have connected the graphic sexuality in Acker's work to a critique of sexual relations as economic relations. Some have interpreted her "transgressive sexuality" as anarchist or even neoliberal. For Michael Clune for example, "Acker's treatment of the incest taboo and her celebration of masochism, show her trans- gressive machine in action, cutting away the malignant apparatus of sovereignty and revealing the positive and natural freedom of the market underneath" (2004, 495).
  7. For Mae Henderson for example, "Acker's heroines are deeply transgressive, contin- ually breaching social taboos associated with female identity and, particularly, sex- uality -indeed, transgression drives the various narratives." (212) Spencer Dew has pointed out that reading Acker as transgressive risks romanticizing sexuality in her work as "rebellious".
  8. 1995 "From Mascot to Doyenne to the Avant-Garde" by Judy Stone in Publisher's Weekly.
  9. "Acker Attacks!" Interview with Dave Thorpe in Monochrome Brixton (1986). Ira Silverberg Papers at NYU Special Collections.
  10. According to Dave Thorpe in the same interview. He asks Acker about her involve- ment in the anti-pornography movement: "Acker fought the anti-porn bill, though she was in a group called Women Against Pornography which some feminists find hard to understand. "The bill was totally oppressive to gays. This is not solidarity of women, I admit. But if I'm stopped in the name of feminism, that to me is an obscenity, it isn't feminism."
  11. Allen, Leah Claire. 2016. "Andrea Dworkin as Literary Critic" Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 2016, vol. 42, no. 1
  12. Naked Lunch was the subject of one of the last major literary censorship cases in the United States when Grove Press was sued in Massachusetts.
  13. Cited in Lorna N. Bracewell's Why We Lost the Sex Wars (2021), p. 41.
  14. Dworkin opens Woman Hating: a Radical Look at Sexuality as follows: "This book References Acker, K. (1997). Bodies of work. Serpent's Tail.
  15. Acker, K. (1984). Blood and guts in high school. Grove Press.
  16. Acker, K. (1988). Empire of the senseless. Picador.
  17. Acker, K. (1998). Portrait of an eye. Grove Press.
  18. Acker, K. (1991). Hannibal Lecter, my father. Semiotext(e).
  19. Allen, L. C. (2016). Andrea Dworkin as literary critic. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 42(1), 49-70. https://doi.org/10.1086/686977
  20. Berlant, L., & Edelman, L. (2013). Sex, or the unbearable. Duke University Press.
  21. Berlant, L. (2022). The inconvenience of other people. Duke University Press.
  22. Bracewell, L. N. (2021). Why we lost the sex wars: Sexual freedom in the #metoo era. University of Minnesota Press.
  23. Califia, P. (1984). "Kathy Acker: a survivor's vision of sex and social change." Unpaginated. The Advocate Ira Silverberg Papers (box 29), Fales Library, New York University.
  24. Carr, C. (1987). Text and violence: Acker strikes again. In The village voice literary sup- plement, March 1987. Ira Silverberg Papers (box 39). NYU Special Collections.
  25. Clune, M. (2004). Blood money: Sovereignty and exchange in Kathy Acker. Contemporary Literature, 45(3), 486-515. https://doi.org/10.1353/cli.2004.0020
  26. Colby, G. (2016). Kathy Acker: Writing the impossible. Edinburgh University Press.
  27. Dworkin, A. (2019). Last Days at Hot Slit edited by Scholder, A. & Fateman, J. Semiotext(e).
  28. Foucault, M. (1977). Preface to transgression. In Language, counter-memory, practice: Selected essays and interviews. Cornell University Press.
  29. Foucault, M. (1989). Foucault live. Semiotext(e).
  30. Gajoux, J. (2019). Kathy Acker and sex work in the section From Diary. In Kathy Acker 1971-1975. Éditions Ismael.
  31. Henderson, M. (2017). Kathy Acker's punk feminism. Contemporary Women's Writing, 11(2), 201-220. https://doi.org/10.1093/cww/vpw037
  32. Ioanes, A. (2016). Shock and consent in feminist Avant-Garde: Kathleen Hanna Reads Kathy Acker. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 42(1), 175-197. https:// doi.org/10.1086/686757
  33. Jackson, R. (1987). "The Vision is: There is no joy." Unpaginated. Ira Silverberg Papers (box 29), Fales Library, New York University.
  34. Kraus, C. (2018). After Kathy Acker: A biography. Penguin Books.
  35. Lawlor, L. & Nale, John. (2014). The Cambridge Foucault Lexicon. Cambridge University Press.
  36. Looze, L. D. (1997). Pseudo-autobiography in the fourteenth century. University Press of Florida.
  37. Martin, D. A. (2017). Acker. Nightboat Books.
  38. McBride, J. (2022). Eat your mind: The radical life and work of Kathy Acker. Simon & Schuster. 2022.
  39. Panel Discussion About Pornography [video]. (1987). Atria, Institute on gender equality and women's history.
  40. Parfrey, A. (1989). Rants and incendiary tracts: Voices of desperate illumination 1558-pres- ent. Amok Press.
  41. Patton, C., & Acker, K. (1984). Post-punk feminism. Women's Review of Books, 1(7), 11-12. https://doi.org/10.2307/4019390
  42. Scholder, Amy, Carla Harryman, Avital Ronell, eds. (2006). Lust for life: On the writings of Kathy Acker. Verso Books.
  43. Schuster. A. (2016). One or many antisexes? Introduction to Andrei Platonov's the an- ti-sexus. Stasis, 4(1), 20-35. https://doi.org/10.33280/2310-3817-2016-4-1-20-35
  44. Wark, M. (2021). Philosophy for spiders: On the low theory of Kathy Acker. Duke University Press.

FAQs

sparkles

AI

What explains Acker's perspective on feminist literature in her works?add

Acker's writing is critiqued for failing to imagine a world beyond patriarchy, offering no useful feminist politics. Critics describe her work as symptomatic of nihilism and lacking psychological depth, contrasting with feminist goals of empowerment.

How did Acker's sex work influence her literary experimentation?add

Acker's experiences in the sex industry significantly shaped her literary output, blending found material and pseudo-autobiography. During the 1970s, she recorded overheard conversations and personal anecdotes, leading to experimental texts reflective of her radicalization.

When did Acker's writings gain notoriety, and for what reasons?add

Acker's novel 'Blood and Guts in High School' gained attention after being banned in Germany in 1984 for depictions of child exploitation. The controversy highlighted the violent portrayals in her works, drawing both criticism and acclaim.

How does Acker's pseudo-autobiography challenge traditional narrative forms?add

Acker's pseudo-autobiographical strategies blur the lines between fact and fiction, questioning self-knowledge and authenticity. Her works utilize autobiographical features to present false claims, exposing the instability of truth in personal narrative.

What role does sexual violence play in Acker's critique of power relations?add

Sexual violence in Acker's work serves as a site for examining power dynamics, challenging both patriarchal structures and feminist responses. Her narratives illustrate an intertwined relationship between victimization and agency, complicating traditional feminist discourse.